GroundUp reports that twenty-two former mine workers are claiming more than R80 million in damages from Sasol Coal after they contracted serious lung and other diseases as a result of years of inhaling coal dust while working in underground coal mines.
They are arguing that Sasol Coal was negligent in failing to take adequate care to maintain healthy working conditions underground, in violation of several health and safety laws. Even if it was not negligent, the miners say the company bears the liability of their ill-health and loss of income for being unable to work.
The miners are represented by Richard Spoor, the attorney who last year reached a R5 billion settlement with seven gold mining companies for miners afflicted with silicosis contracted after years of breathing silica dust in underground mines.
In papers before the High Court in Johannesburg, 12 of the 22 miners say they were dismissed from employment because they contracted lung-related illnesses which made them unable to continue working. They are claiming for the loss of income, aggravated by their inability to find alternative work due to age, illness, low educational levels and lack of qualifications.
The largest individual claim is R10.2 million and the smallest is just under R1 million.
“The plaintiffs have suffered permanent physical impairment. Such impairment includes shortness of breath, generalised weakness, chronic chest discomfort, tiredness and disturbed sleep,” states the miners’ particulars of claim before the court.
One of the principal hazards to which they were exposed was noxious coal dust that causes lung diseases such as coal workers’ pneumoconiosis (CWP) and chronic pulmonary disease (COPD). These diseases can lead to respiratory symptoms such as a persistent cough and shortness of breath, resulting in a reduced ability to perform physical tasks.
These can eventually develop into progressive massive fibrosis, which reduces life expectancy. If coal miners with CWP or COPD are further exposed to coal dust, the severity of the disease is likely to increase.
The miners argue that Sasol Coal should have known of these health hazards and through dust sampling and measurement should have been aware of the quantities of coal dust to which miners were exposed. Routine medical surveillance, if undertaken, would have established whether miners were at risk from the levels of dust in the underground mines.
In its reply, Sasol Coal argues that the matter has prescribed – meaning it is now too late to bring before the court. The Prescription Act requires such matters to be brought within three years of the alleged offence.
Summons was served on the company in April 2015, more than three years after most of the miners had left Sasol’s employ.
Sasol Coal’s court papers show several of the miners were dismissed for illegal strike action and some had received medical compensation once their conditions had been diagnosed. One of the miners has since passed away.
In other cases, workers’ medical conditions were deemed not severe enough for compensation. Some of the miners had previously worked at other mines,
The original of this report by Ciaran Ryan appeared on page 9 of The Citizen of 26 April
Get other news reports at the SA Labour News home page